Oncast News · The World

Pakistan Astronaut Joins China Space Mission

· Fact-checked before it aired. Unconfirmed claims from this segment are not shown.

India had atheistic/non-theistic schools of thought by the 6th century BCE; Charvaka/Lokayata rejected gods and the Vedas, and some orthodox Hindu schools such as Samkhya and early Mimamsa reject a personal creator god. Charvaka is usually classified as heterodox, not one of the six orthodox schools.

Fact-check

VERIFIED TRUE

India had atheistic/non-theistic schools of thought by the 6th century BCE; Charvaka/Lokayata rejected gods and the Vedas, and some orthodox Hindu schools such as Samkhya and early Mimamsa reject a personal creator god. Charvaka is usually classified as heterodox, not one of the six orthodox schools.

Atheism is a fully recognized school of thought within Hinduism, originating in India by the 6th century BCE, long before the Western world. Therefore, opposing atheistic traditions contradicts the very spirit of Hinduism. https://t.co/D4ez0w4iZV https://t.co/OqenJ7qDCV

Original post · Indian Geostrat (@IndianGeostrat)

[wikipedia.org](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinduatheism), [opendoubt.com](https://opendoubt.com/hinduism)

Sources

What the hosts said

BAl Jazeera English is reporting that a Pakistani astronaut is about to fly on China’s next space station mission.
BThat’s a bigger deal than it sounds.
BIt’s one astronaut, Brian. Pakistan and China have been getting closer for years.
BExactly. China is building its own orbit club, and it’s handing out seats to its allies.
BOne seat on a mission isn’t a strategic shift. It’s science and training.
BScience? China’s station isn’t just for experiments. It’s a diplomatic tool.
BEvery space program has dual-use potential. The US does the same with partners.
BThe difference is China is setting the rules in that orbit now.
BSetting the rules? It has one station, not a blockade.
BIt’s not a blockade. It’s a gateway. Pakistan gets access it can’t build alone.
BSo Beijing becomes indispensable. I get that.
BThen why are you acting like this is just a nice human-interest story?
BBecause for a Pakistani kid watching, it IS a nice human-interest story. A countryman in space.
BBoth can be true. But the geopolitics matter more right now.
BMaybe to you. To me, it’s a milestone, not a new space race.
BNot a new space race? China is training astronauts from Pakistan, maybe soon more. That is how influence works.
BInfluence, yes. Military takeover, no. Let’s keep the scale right.
BFine. But Washington should pay attention.
BWashington should pay attention to a lot of things. This one isn’t top of the list.
BI’ll give you that. But it’s on the list.
BOkay. Moving on.
BSpeaking of South Asia and belief, a post from Indian Geostrat on X makes a historical point about India.
BGo on.
BThe post says atheism is a fully recognized school of thought within Hinduism, originating in India by the sixth century BCE, long before the Western world.
BThat’s true. India had atheistic and non-theistic schools back then.
BThen it goes further: “opposing atheistic traditions contradicts the very spirit of Hinduism.”
BOne correction: the best-known atheist school, Charvaka, is usually classified as heterodox, not one of the six orthodox schools. But the broader point stands.
BHere’s where I push back. Using ancient history to win modern political arguments is tricky.
BWhy? The history is real. If someone claims India has always been one religious tradition, that’s false.
BBecause modern India’s debates are about nationalism and identity, not sixth-century philosophers.
BBut that history matters. It complicates the story that being Indian means one specific faith.
BSo now we’re doing theology on a war show?
BYou brought the post.
BI did. But it’s a useful reminder: India’s tradition is more diverse than the loudest voices claim.
BThat’s exactly the point. And that’s why I like it.
BOkay, I accept the history. Just don’t make me recite the Vedas.
BNot on air. History keeps the present honest.

Cite this story as https://oncast.fm/story/1794070052218-news-segment-pakistan-astronaut-joins-china-space-mission. Fact-check by Oncast. Cite the original sources above too.

Listen live on Oncast