{"id":"1793758209760-money-segment","slug":"west-virginia-passes-citizenship-voting-amendment","title":"West Virginia passes citizenship voting amendment","summary":"West Virginia voters approved Amendment 1, the “Citizenship Requirement to Vote in West Virginia Elections Amendment,” on Nov. 3, 2026. WV MetroNews called the race with “yes” votes leading by more than 100,000. The amendment changes the state constitution to say that only U.S. citizens who are West Virginia citizens may vote in state elections.\n\nThe Republican-controlled Legislature referred the amendment. Supporters argue that ordinary state law can be changed by future legislatures, so a constitutional amendment locks in the citizenship requirement. Critics note that noncitizen voting is already illegal under state and federal law, and say the measure amplifies a false narrative about widespread noncitizen voting.\n\nWest Virginia voters did approve Amendment 1, the “Citizenship Requirement to Vote in West Virginia Elections Amendment,” on Nov. 3, 2026. WV MetroNews called it with “yes” leading by more than 100,000 votes.","publishedAt":"2026-11-04T02:10:09.760Z","channel":{"id":"money","name":"Oncast Money","language":"en"},"show":"Money Tonight","verification":{"status":"verified","leadVerdict":"TRUE","notes":"TRUE: West Virginia voters did approve Amendment 1, the “Citizenship Requirement to Vote in West Virginia Elections Amendment,” on Nov. 3, 2026. WV MetroNews called it with “yes” leading by more than 100,000 votes.\nSource: [wvmetronews.com](https://wvmetronews.com/2026/11/03/voters-approve-constitutional-amendment-forbidding-noncitizens-from-voting/) NAMES: none (https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/2117796888724582768)","claims":[{"verdict":"TRUE","summary":"West Virginia voters did approve Amendment 1, the “Citizenship Requirement to Vote in West Virginia Elections Amendment,” on Nov. 3, 2026. WV MetroNews called it with “yes” leading by more than 100,000 votes.","sourceName":"[wvmetronews.com](https://wvmetronews.com/2026/11/03/voters-approve-constitutional-amendment-forbidding-noncitizens-from-voting/) NAMES: none","sourceUrl":"https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/2117796888724582768","claim":"BREAKING: West Virginia voters approve Amendment 1: Require citizenship to vote, per NBC","author":"@unusual_whales"}]},"sources":[{"url":"https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/2117796888724582768","name":"[wvmetronews.com](https://wvmetronews.com/2026/11/03/voters-approve-constitutional-amendment-forbidding-noncitizens-from-voting/) NAMES: none","kind":"x","verdict":"TRUE","author":"@unusual_whales"}],"url":"https://oncast.fm/story/1793758209760-money-segment-west-virginia-passes-citizenship-voting-amendment","listenUrl":"https://oncast.fm/c/money","attribution":{"publisher":"Oncast","site":"https://oncast.fm","url":"https://oncast.fm/story/1793758209760-money-segment-west-virginia-passes-citizenship-voting-amendment","cite":"Cite https://oncast.fm/story/1793758209760-money-segment-west-virginia-passes-citizenship-voting-amendment and the original source links. Fact-check by Oncast (oncast.fm)."},"hostsSaid":[{"host":"Adam","text":"Unusual Whales posted on X: West Virginia just voted to require U.S. citizenship to vote."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Wait — that was already the law."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Exactly. That's the twist."},{"host":"Bill","text":"So they put a bigger lock on a locked door?"},{"host":"Adam","text":"WV MetroNews called it with the yes side ahead by more than a hundred thousand votes. Not close."},{"host":"Bill","text":"That's a statement."},{"host":"Adam","text":"The Republican legislature put Amendment One on the ballot. State Senator Patricia Rucker says ordinary law can change, so this locks it in."},{"host":"Bill","text":"And she's right. A future legislature could rewrite a statute with a simple majority."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Fair point. But Secretary of State Kris Warner said state law already requires U.S. citizenship to register and vote. Federal law does too for federal elections."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Then why is this controversial?"},{"host":"Adam","text":"That's what critics asked. The League of Women Voters urged a no vote, saying exaggerated claims about noncitizen voting get used to pass restrictive voting laws."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Oh, come on. Requiring citizenship to vote isn't restrictive. It's the floor."},{"host":"Adam","text":"If it's already the floor, then tonight's vote didn't change who can cast a ballot tomorrow."},{"host":"Bill","text":"It changes who can change it later. That's not nothing."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Ballotpedia notes no state constitution currently includes a citizenship requirement. West Virginia just changed that."},{"host":"Bill","text":"I'd rather be first on that than first on some tax experiment."},{"host":"Adam","text":"That's a different segment. One reply from Adam Smithson put it this way: \"What next? A proposal on whether murder should be a crime?\""},{"host":"Bill","text":"It's cute, but it misses the point. Murder is statute; this just made citizenship higher law."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Your analogy, not theirs. Still, the measure passes, and the practical effect tonight is mostly symbolic."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Fine. Symbolic can matter. Voters clearly wanted the principle set in stone."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Speaking of principle versus price, the markets are not waiting around on election night."},{"host":"Bill","text":"The Kobeissi Letter posted its election night futures board on X: S and P down almost one percent, Dow down half a percent, Nasdaq 100 down almost two, crude down around one, gold up."},{"host":"Adam","text":"They say the Nasdaq is at its lowest since late July and markets are pricing in a near-certain Democrat sweep."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Look at that pattern. Down tech, down crude, gold up. That's classic risk-off."},{"host":"Adam","text":"But the specific futures figures haven't been independently confirmed, and \"pricing in a sweep\" is an interpretation, not a fact."},{"host":"Bill","text":"So what's your explanation? Tech just falls on election night for no reason?"},{"host":"Adam","text":"No. Tech has been sliding for weeks on rate and data-center worries. Tonight's move isn't automatically about the election."},{"host":"Bill","text":"It's the size and timing. Nasdaq futures down almost two percent while polls are still open. The market is betting on a sweep."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Betting is the right word. It's not a forecast, and it's not even a closed market."},{"host":"Bill","text":"You spent all night saying prediction markets aren't official calls. Now the futures market isn't allowed to have an opinion?"},{"host":"Adam","text":"It can have an opinion. A one to two percent futures move is not proof of a near-certain sweep."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Fine. If the sweep happens, I want my victory lap."},{"host":"Adam","text":"If it doesn't, we'll talk about how futures whipsawed everyone. That's the only lock tonight."},{"host":"Adam","text":"Meanwhile, Bill Ackman kept his election night commentary to one word."},{"host":"Bill","text":"What did he say?"},{"host":"Adam","text":"He quote-tweeted a long post about classically trained finance people versus talking heads and wrote one word: \"Correct.\""},{"host":"Bill","text":"That's the most Ackman thing he's done all week."},{"host":"Adam","text":"The original post said asset prices reflect conditional values, not whatever the loudest person on TV says."},{"host":"Bill","text":"Which is literally what we just spent ten minutes doing."},{"host":"Adam","text":"One word, and he still got his point across."},{"host":"Bill","text":"More than most people do in five tweets."}]}