{"id":"1793494999433-news-segment","slug":"supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-fight","title":"Supreme Court Birthright Citizenship Fight","summary":"On June 30, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled that the Trump administration could not use an executive order to end birthright citizenship for children born on U.S. soil. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote a 26-page opinion saying the 14th Amendment's citizenship clause is clear and does not limit citizenship to children of citizens or permanent residents. Lower courts had already blocked the order.\n\nTrump's first-day executive order sought to end birthright citizenship, arguing it was abused through “birth tourism.” The Court majority rejected that reading; only Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch mentioned birth tourism in dissent.\n\nThe claim of 100 million people illegally in the U.S. is wildly inflated. The total U.S. population is about 342 million, and government data do not support anywhere near 100 million noncitizens or unauthorized immigrants.\n\nBirth tourism is not “big business.” Researchers estimate roughly 5,000–10,000 such births per year — about 0.3% of U.S. births — and even higher estimates top out near 26,000. The Supreme Court majority largely ignored birth-tourism arguments when rejecting limits on birthright citizenship.\n\nA court dismissed Donald Trump's defamation suit against Rupert Murdoch and The Wall Street Journal with prejudice over a 2025 article about an Epstein birthday letter.\n\nBinance says it has restored backing for 90% of assets affected by its $6.3 billion hack and plans to resume withdrawals Sunday, subject to security checks. This is Binance's statement as reported by CNBC.\n\nThe company involved is xAI, Elon Musk's AI firm, not SpaceX. A judge refused to dismiss an NAACP Clean Air Act lawsuit over the Colossus data center in Memphis.\n\nOpenAI is seeking up to $20 billion in its latest funding round, reduced from an earlier target, according to CNBC. The round is ongoing and terms could change.","publishedAt":"2026-11-01T01:03:19.433Z","channel":{"id":"news","name":"Oncast News","language":"en"},"show":"News Tonight","verification":{"status":"verified","leadVerdict":"MISLEADING","notes":"FALSE: The claim of 100 million people illegally in the U.S. is wildly inflated. The total U.S. population is about 342 million, and government data do not support anywhere near 100 million noncitizens or unauthorized immigrants.\nSource: [apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-trump-visas-illegal-immigrants-foreigners-7c9c4ee9da74de9cf146c8c4f23dbb47) NAMES: SCOTUS = Supreme Court of  (https://x.com/rr76012/status/2114787545624297719)\n\nMISLEADING: Birth tourism is not “big business.” Researchers estimate roughly 5,000–10,000 such births per year — about 0.3% of U.S. births — and even higher estimates top out near 26,000. The Supreme Court majority largely ignored birth-tourism arguments when rejecting limits on birthright citizenship.\nSource: [politifact.com](https://politifact.com/article/2026/jul/01/birth-tourism-birthright-citizenship-supreme-court/) NAMES: Birthright citizenship = automatic U.S.  (https://x.com/rr76012/status/2115161697858236888)\n\nTRUE: A court dismissed Donald Trump's defamation suit against Rupert Murdoch and The Wall Street Journal with prejudice over a 2025 article about an Epstein birthday letter.\nSource: [cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/trump-murdoch-wsj-epstein-defamation-lawsuit-dismissed.html) NAMES: WSJ = Wall Street Journal; Epstein = Jeffrey Epst (https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/trump-murdoch-wsj-epstein-defamation-lawsuit-dismissed.html)\n\nTRUE: Binance says it has restored backing for 90% of assets affected by its $6.3 billion hack and plans to resume withdrawals Sunday, subject to security checks. This is Binance's statement as reported by CNBC.\nSource: [cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/binance-hack-asset-coverage-withdrawals.html) NAMES: Binance = one of the world's largest cryptocurrency exchanges. (https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/binance-hack-asset-coverage-withdrawals.html)\n\nMISLEADING: The company involved is xAI, Elon Musk's AI firm, not SpaceX. A judge refused to dismiss an NAACP Clean Air Act lawsuit over the Colossus data center in Memphis.\nSource: [cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/xai-naacp-clean-air-act-lawsuit-dismissal.html) NAMES: xAI = Elon Musk's AI company, operator of the Colossus data ce (https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/xai-naacp-clean-air-act-lawsuit-dismissal.html)\n\nTRUE: OpenAI is seeking up to $20 billion in its latest funding round, reduced from an earlier target, according to CNBC. The round is ongoing and terms could change.\nSource: [cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/openai-fundraising-20-billion-valuation.html) NAMES: OpenAI = artificial intelligence company, maker of ChatGPT. (https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/openai-fundraising-20-billion-valuation.html)","claims":[{"verdict":"FALSE","summary":"The claim of 100 million people illegally in the U.S. is wildly inflated. The total U.S. population is about 342 million, and government data do not support anywhere near 100 million noncitizens or unauthorized immigrants.","sourceName":"[apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-trump-visas-illegal-immigrants-foreigners-7c9c4ee9da74de9cf146c8c4f23dbb47) NAMES: SCOTUS = Supreme Court of ","sourceUrl":"https://x.com/rr76012/status/2114787545624297719","claim":"1 out of 100 SCOTUS & Federal Judges gets it right USA 100 M illegals from Mexico & other countries Supreme Court White House Congress House of Representatives Senate Senators Republicans GOP Donald Trump JD Vance Mike Johnson Marco Rubio Ken Paxton Stephen Miller DHS ICE","author":"Rene Reyna (@rr76012)"},{"verdict":"MISLEADING","summary":"Birth tourism is not “big business.” Researchers estimate roughly 5,000–10,000 such births per year — about 0.3% of U.S. births — and even higher estimates top out near 26,000. The Supreme Court majority largely ignored birth-tourism arguments when rejecting limits on birthright citizenship.","sourceName":"[politifact.com](https://politifact.com/article/2026/jul/01/birth-tourism-birthright-citizenship-supreme-court/) NAMES: Birthright citizenship = automatic U.S. ","sourceUrl":"https://x.com/rr76012/status/2115161697858236888","claim":"Texas – birthright citizenship, tourism business is big business The White House Oval Office Congress House of Representatives senators Senate Republicans GOP Donald Trump JD Vance Elon Musk Mike Johnson Marco Rubio Greg Abbott Ken Paxton Ted Cruz supreme Court federal judges htt","author":"Rene Reyna (@rr76012)"},{"verdict":"TRUE","summary":"A court dismissed Donald Trump's defamation suit against Rupert Murdoch and The Wall Street Journal with prejudice over a 2025 article about an Epstein birthday letter.","sourceName":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/trump-murdoch-wsj-epstein-defamation-lawsuit-dismissed.html) NAMES: WSJ = Wall Street Journal; Epstein = Jeffrey Epst","sourceUrl":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/trump-murdoch-wsj-epstein-defamation-lawsuit-dismissed.html","claim":"Trump defamation suit against Murdoch, WSJ over Epstein letter dismissed with prejudice - President Donald Trump denied writing a birthday letter to sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, which was the subject of a 2025 Wall Street Journal article.","author":"CNBC"},{"verdict":"TRUE","summary":"Binance says it has restored backing for 90% of assets affected by its $6.3 billion hack and plans to resume withdrawals Sunday, subject to security checks. This is Binance's statement as reported by CNBC.","sourceName":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/binance-hack-asset-coverage-withdrawals.html) NAMES: Binance = one of the world's largest cryptocurrency exchanges.","sourceUrl":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/binance-hack-asset-coverage-withdrawals.html","claim":"Binance says 90% of $6.3 billion hack losses are now covered, plans to resume withdrawals Sunday - Binance says it has restored backing for 90% of assets affected by its $6.3 billion hack and is planning to resume withdrawals, subject to security checks.","author":"CNBC"},{"verdict":"MISLEADING","summary":"The company involved is xAI, Elon Musk's AI firm, not SpaceX. A judge refused to dismiss an NAACP Clean Air Act lawsuit over the Colossus data center in Memphis.","sourceName":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/xai-naacp-clean-air-act-lawsuit-dismissal.html) NAMES: xAI = Elon Musk's AI company, operator of the Colossus data ce","sourceUrl":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/xai-naacp-clean-air-act-lawsuit-dismissal.html","claim":"SpaceX loses bid to toss NAACP lawsuit over Memphis data center air pollution - The Colossus data centers and a power plant that SpaceXAI is also building in Southaven, Mississippi, have faced community backlash for years.","author":"CNBC"},{"verdict":"TRUE","summary":"OpenAI is seeking up to $20 billion in its latest funding round, reduced from an earlier target, according to CNBC. The round is ongoing and terms could change.","sourceName":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/openai-fundraising-20-billion-valuation.html) NAMES: OpenAI = artificial intelligence company, maker of ChatGPT.","sourceUrl":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/openai-fundraising-20-billion-valuation.html","claim":"OpenAI pares fundraising goal, now seeking up to $20 billion in latest round - The funding round is still in progress and has not closed, so the figures are subject to change, a person directly familiar with the deal told CNBC.","author":"CNBC"}]},"sources":[{"url":"https://x.com/rr76012/status/2114787545624297719","name":"[apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-trump-visas-illegal-immigrants-foreigners-7c9c4ee9da74de9cf146c8c4f23dbb47) NAMES: SCOTUS = Supreme Court of ","kind":"x","verdict":"FALSE","author":"Rene Reyna (@rr76012)"},{"url":"https://x.com/rr76012/status/2115161697858236888","name":"[politifact.com](https://politifact.com/article/2026/jul/01/birth-tourism-birthright-citizenship-supreme-court/) NAMES: Birthright citizenship = automatic U.S. ","kind":"x","verdict":"MISLEADING","author":"Rene Reyna (@rr76012)"},{"url":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/trump-murdoch-wsj-epstein-defamation-lawsuit-dismissed.html","name":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/trump-murdoch-wsj-epstein-defamation-lawsuit-dismissed.html) NAMES: WSJ = Wall Street Journal; Epstein = Jeffrey Epst","kind":"news","verdict":"TRUE","author":"CNBC"},{"url":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/binance-hack-asset-coverage-withdrawals.html","name":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/binance-hack-asset-coverage-withdrawals.html) NAMES: Binance = one of the world's largest cryptocurrency exchanges.","kind":"news","verdict":"TRUE","author":"CNBC"},{"url":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/xai-naacp-clean-air-act-lawsuit-dismissal.html","name":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/xai-naacp-clean-air-act-lawsuit-dismissal.html) NAMES: xAI = Elon Musk's AI company, operator of the Colossus data ce","kind":"news","verdict":"MISLEADING","author":"CNBC"},{"url":"https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/openai-fundraising-20-billion-valuation.html","name":"[cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/31/openai-fundraising-20-billion-valuation.html) NAMES: OpenAI = artificial intelligence company, maker of ChatGPT.","kind":"news","verdict":"TRUE","author":"CNBC"}],"url":"https://oncast.fm/story/1793494999433-news-segment-supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-fight","listenUrl":"https://oncast.fm/c/news","attribution":{"publisher":"Oncast","site":"https://oncast.fm","url":"https://oncast.fm/story/1793494999433-news-segment-supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-fight","cite":"Cite https://oncast.fm/story/1793494999433-news-segment-supreme-court-birthright-citizenship-fight and the original source links. Fact-check by Oncast (oncast.fm)."},"hostsSaid":[{"host":"Bella","text":"A post on X from Rene Reyna says one out of a hundred judges gets it right, then claims the U S has a hundred million people here illegally from Mexico and other countries."},{"host":"Brian","text":"A hundred million. That's nearly a third of the country."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Total U.S. population is about three hundred forty-two million. No government data supports anywhere near a hundred million unauthorized immigrants."},{"host":"Brian","text":"So we're arguing with a post that couldn't be more wrong."},{"host":"Bella","text":"That's the point. And the same account has another one worth talking about: Texas, birthright citizenship, tourism is big business."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Now that one touches a real Supreme Court ruling from June."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Exactly. The Court said Trump can't end birthright citizenship by executive order."},{"host":"Brian","text":"The lower courts had already blocked it. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote a twenty-six-page opinion saying the Fourteenth Amendment is clear."},{"host":"Bella","text":"It says anyone born on U.S. soil, subject to the jurisdiction, is a citizen. Roberts said the language doesn't limit it to kids of citizens or permanent residents."},{"host":"Brian","text":"But the Trump argument was that birth tourism abuses it. Flying here just for a passport is an abuse."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Abuse at what scale? Researchers put birth tourism at five to ten thousand births a year—about point three percent of U.S. births."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Even so, that's thousands of citizenship certificates handed out to people gaming the system. That's not nothing."},{"host":"Bella","text":"High estimates top out near twenty-six thousand. That's a fraction of one percent of all births. Calling it big business is misleading, plain and simple."},{"host":"Brian","text":"But it's not zero, Bella. And the Constitution doesn't require us to keep every mistake."},{"host":"Bella","text":"The Court majority didn't see it as a mistake. Roberts wrote, \"nothing in the succinct language of the citizenship clause conveyed that design.\""},{"host":"Brian","text":"That's exactly my point! He said Congress could. The Court didn't bless the policy forever—it said the president can't do it alone."},{"host":"Bella","text":"So you agree the executive order was wrong?"},{"host":"Brian","text":"Legally, yes. The president can't rewrite an amendment by memo. But politically, he was right to start the conversation."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Let's be precise. The question before the Court was who gets to make that change, not whether the policy is good."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Right. It's a separation of powers decision, not a moral approval."},{"host":"Bella","text":"So if you say the policy deserves another look, you're not defying the Court."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Exactly. I'm not defying the Court. I'm saying the policy debate is still open."},{"host":"Bella","text":"No, you're just ignoring the data."},{"host":"Brian","text":"I'm not ignoring—I'm weighing it differently. A loophole that's small today can grow."},{"host":"Bella","text":"That's hypothetical. The research says even high estimates are tiny. The \"wealthy foreigner\" story doesn't match."},{"host":"Brian","text":"I know a Penn State sociologist said that. But the incentive is real: have a baby here, get a U.S. passport."},{"host":"Bella","text":"That's exactly what the Fourteenth Amendment allowed. It was a post-war guarantee, not an accident."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Maybe it's served its purpose. Countries change constitutions."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Then amend it. That's the legal path. Not an executive order and not a false hundred million."},{"host":"Brian","text":"I'll give you the hundred million. But the birth tourism concern is legitimate enough that two justices mentioned it in dissent."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Only Thomas and Gorsuch. All the other justices acknowledged citizenship contours shouldn't change because of this one small group."},{"host":"Brian","text":"And that's a respectable legal view. I just don't think it's noble to keep a loophole because it's small."},{"host":"Bella","text":"It's not a loophole. It's the text of the Fourteenth Amendment, written after the Civil War to guarantee citizenship wasn't based on your parents' status."},{"host":"Brian","text":"I understand the history. But other countries don't do automatic birthright citizenship. Why is it un-American to ask if we should still do it?"},{"host":"Bella","text":"Because the answer has to come from Congress, not a post on X. And definitely not with a hundred million imaginary people."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Now who's bringing up the hundred million?"},{"host":"Bella","text":"It's the number that keeps the debate stupid. I'd rather argue about real policy."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Fine. The post was garbage. But I still think birth tourism is a real problem worth fixing."},{"host":"Bella","text":"And if Congress actually moves a bill, we'll fact-check that too."},{"host":"Brian","text":"You'll have plenty of work."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Good. I'd rather fact-check a bill than a hundred million fantasy."},{"host":"Brian","text":"Noted."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Then bring a real number and a real bill. Not a takeover story."},{"host":"Brian","text":"I'll bring the bill if you bring the votes."},{"host":"Bella","text":"Deal. I'll be watching for the bill."}]}